Learn

CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading

Back to topics
CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading

1. Task overview

Comparing and Persuading is Task 5 of the CELPIP Speaking test. This is the only speaking task with two stages. First, you choose one of two options. The options are shown in pictures. Then you speak to a person who likes the other option more, and you try to persuade that person. Persuade means you try to change the person's mind with good reasons.
This task tests more than speaking. It tests if you can compare two things, choose one, and defend your choice in a friendly and clear way.

2. Facts box

Item Detail
Time for this part About 3 minutes in total
Questions 1 question, in two stages
Format Stage 1: you choose one of two options shown in pictures. Stage 2: you record a spoken answer to persuade another person
Choosing time 60 seconds to choose. This part is not recorded
Preparation 60 seconds to prepare your answer
Speaking 60 seconds
Replay There is no replay. Your recording is saved once

3. Task structure

  • • Stage 1, choosing (60 seconds, not recorded). You see two options in pictures. You choose the option you like more. Think about reasons while you choose, because your preparation time starts right after this stage.
  • • Stage 2, preparation (60 seconds). You prepare your answer. The person you will speak to prefers the other option.
  • • Stage 3, speaking (60 seconds). You record your answer. You speak directly to the other person and try to persuade them.

4. What to expect

  • • The two options are everyday choices, for example two gifts, two places, two activities, or two products.
  • • The pictures show the important differences between the options. Look at the pictures carefully during the choosing time.
  • • The other person is not real. You speak to the idea of that person, but you should talk as if the person is in front of you.
  • • Sixty seconds of speaking is short. You need a clear plan, not many ideas.

5. Strategies and tips

  • 1. Use the choosing time for reasons, not only for the choice. Choose fast, in the first 10 to 15 seconds. Then spend the rest of the choosing time thinking of two reasons for your choice and one good point of the other option.
  • 2. Plan the other side too. In your preparation time, write or think of the name of the other choice and one small good point it has. You will use this in your first sentences.
  • 3. Plan two clear reasons. Pick reasons that are easy to explain with a small example or detail. Two strong reasons are better than four weak ones.
  • 4. Speak to the person. Use direct sentences, for example "I know you prefer the red bike, but..." Direct speech makes your answer sound real and natural.
  • 5. Watch the clock. Finish your second reason before the last 10 seconds, so you have time for a short closing sentence.
Suggested timing inside the speaking minute: about 10 seconds to name the other choice and agree with one small good point, about 20 seconds for your first reason, about 20 seconds for your second reason, and about 10 seconds to close.

6. Scoring

Trained human raters listen to your recording later. They score four things:
  • • Content and Coherence. Coherence means your ideas connect in a clear order. Your reasons must be clear, in a logical order, and easy to follow.
  • • Vocabulary. You use words that fit the topic. Correct, natural words score better than rare, difficult words used in a wrong way.
  • • Listenability. This is how easy it is to listen to you. Raters listen to your rhythm, your pronunciation, your pauses, your grammar, and if you use different kinds of sentences.
  • • Task Fulfillment. You do what the task asks. In this task, that means you name the other choice, you answer its good point, and you give reasons for your choice.
A lower level answer usually gives one short reason, or only describes the two pictures. A higher level answer compares the options, speaks directly to the person, and gives two developed reasons with details. The score is for the whole answer, not for one perfect sentence.

7. How to build an answer

How to start. Name your choice and the other choice in your first sentence or two. Agree that the other choice has one small good point. For example: "I know you prefer option B, and it is true that it looks nice." This shows the rater that you understand the task.
How to develop. Give your first reason and a small detail or example. Then give your second reason and a small detail or example. Connect your sentences with simple linking words, for example "first", "also", and "because".
How to finish. End with a short, friendly sentence that repeats your choice. For example: "So, for these reasons, I think my choice is better for us." A clean finish helps your Task Fulfillment score.
One general framework:
  • 1. Say the other choice and agree with one small good point of it.
  • 2. Say your choice clearly.
  • 3. Give reason 1, with a detail.
  • 4. Give reason 2, with a detail.
  • 5. Close with a short sentence that repeats your choice.
A framework is a starting structure, not a script to memorize. Raters can hear memorized scripts, and scripts can pull your answer away from the question. Use the framework to organize your own ideas. On Celpip Easy, the AI feedback on your speaking practice gives you personal help with your own answers, so you do not need to copy a fixed text.

8. Mistakes learners make in this task

  • • Choosing too slowly. If you use all 60 seconds only to choose, you start speaking with no reasons ready.
  • • Forgetting the other choice. If you never name the other option, you do not complete the task. The task asks you to persuade, not only to describe your choice.
  • • Never agreeing with the other side. A small agreement makes your answer stronger. It shows you listened and you are fair.
  • • Only one reason. One reason is usually not enough for 60 seconds. You may stop early or repeat the same idea.
  • • Memorizing a template. A memorized text sounds unnatural and may not fit the pictures. Raters recognize templates, and they can lower your score.
  • • Running out of time. If you speak too slowly at the start, you lose your second reason and your closing sentence.
  • • Silence. Do not stop and say nothing. If you lose a word, say it in a simpler way and keep talking.

9. Practice this task

Reading about the task is step one. The skill comes from doing it under real timing: 60 seconds to choose, 60 seconds to prepare, and 60 seconds to speak.